Once the twice baked potatoes are out of the oven from their second bake, pile on all those remaining toppings you love. Ingredient notes: Potatoes: Starchier potatoes like Russets have sturdy skins and are nice for mashing, superb qualities for making twice-baked spuds. Otherwise you’ll end up with lumpy bits of chewy potatoes throughout the finished product. These twice-baked potatoes are a wonderful change of pace from everyday baked potatoes or the "same-old" mashed potatoes. I will give you some other options for potatoes later on. Scoop your potato mixture out and place in potato skins. I love twice baked potatoes, but I wanted to be able to serve them more easily so I decided to put them in muffin pans. Twice-Baked Potatoes are fancy enough for a special occasion but simple enough for any family dinner. In fact, you could go with any potato and leave the skin on. Idaho potatoes, which hail from their namesake state, are similar to russet potatoes but are a bit smaller. Remove the potatoes to a rack and reduce the oven heat to 375 F. When the potatoes are cool enough to handle, split them lengthwise and scoop the potato into a mixing bowl, taking caution to leave the potato skins intact. Cool slightly; cut in half lengthwise and scoop out pulp, leaving 1/4 in. You will also want to bring your sour cream, butter, and milk to room temperature. You can use either low-fat or full-fat sour cream and milk, though full-fat will yield the best results in terms of flavor and texture of the finished twice baked potato. Cook at 350 degrees for 15 minutes. Finely chopped cilantro and/or jalapeno make nice additions as well, as do crispy bacon bits. Top these potatoes with cheese and your favorite toppings The filling for twice baked potatoes relies on the natural creaminess of a baked potato and takes it up a few notches by adding sour cream, milk, butter, and cheese. Continue mixing it with a fork, trying to blend it until it's cohesive and creamy (though some lumps are okay). When baking potatoes are on special, I buy a 10-15 pound bag and make about 30-35 of these creamy, delicious potatoes for the freezer. Using red potatoes also gives them some color to add to your table. My love for the twice-baked potato knows no bounds. I only caution Except maybe those same twice baked potatoes, topped with all your favorite toppings: tomatoes, cilantro, scallions, and even jalapeno for those who like to keep things spicy. These twice-baked potatoes are a wonderful change of pace from everyday baked potatoes or the "same-old" mashed potatoes. Truthfully though, I havenât often made twice baked potatoes in my adult life, aside from these gouda twice baked potatoes . Once your potatoes have cooled sufficiently, you will want to slice them in half lengthwise. Twice Baked Potatoes are NOT something you're going to make every day. Each potato should look like it Back in the early 2000’s I had a bit of an obsession with twice baked potatoes. They can be frozen as well, but without the scallions — those can be added when reheating. Off the heat, stir in the water and season with black pepper to taste. Beat this mixture until smooth. The twice baked potatoes take about 30-40 minutes from a frozen state, and the skins only take 15-20 minutes. Southern-cuisine expert and cookbook author Diana Rattray has created more than 5,000 recipes articles in her 20 years as a food writer. Store any leftover baked potatoes in a sealed container in the refrigerator for 2 to 3 days. Boil until fork tender, 20 to 30 … Finely dice the cilantro and jalapeno, if using. In a large bowl, mash the scooped out baked potato flesh with a fork or a potato masher for best results. What’s great about twice baked potatoes is that it’s easily customizable. These twice baked potatoes are perfect as a meal themselves or can be used a side for steak, chicken just any protein that you cook up in your Ninja Foodi or Ninja Foodi Grill. Twice Baked Loaded Potatoes are a comforting, hearty, and cheesy side dish. Bake in the oven until the filling is hot and lightly browned, around 20 to 25 minutes. Bake the potatoes for an additional 15 to 20 minutes until the cheese is fully melted, crisped around the edges, and bubbling. It's really up to you here to decide what would taste best on top of your twice baked potatoes, but these are all solid options. Sprinkle half of your cheddar cheese and all of your bacon (crumbled into pieces) on top of potatoes. The second time is after you add the mixture to the remaining potato skins and spread the potatoes … This dish disappears at dinner parties or BBQs. What is better than creamy mashed potatoes? Step 2 Twice Baked Potato Casserole is the ultimate comfort food recipe! And for potato lovers, it's no wonder as it combines creamy mashed potatoes with crispy potato skins. Place empty skins on a tin foil covered baking sheet and set aside. Perfect Baked Potatoes are scooped out and mashed to create super creamy Mashed Potatoesâ¦ we then add in our favorite potato toppings including crispy bacon, â¦ Arrange the stuffed potatoes on a large baking sheet covered with parchment paper or a reusable silicone mat (but make sure you cover your sheet with something to catch all that melting cheese). Combine it with sour cream, milk, butter, salt, pepper, cheese, and scallions. Yukon Gold are also great for baking. For topping our classic twice baked potatoes, we love using fresh tomatoes, fresh scallions, fresh cilantro, and jalapeno peppers for that little kick. Finely diced scallions (or green onions) provide a nice acidic contrast to all that cream, but you can substitute them for regular onion (a quarter of a large onion will do), or skip them altogether if you're not a fan. And watch videos demonstrating recipe prep and cooking techniques. I know she left the skins on and pretty much made mashed potatoes with butter, sour cream, and cheese. Beat until thoroughly mixed, but don't mix to the point of gumminess. Because there's no day that can't be made better with a cheesy twice baked potato. Try to take care not to rip the skin — you may want to leave a thin border of potato flesh all around the perimeter of the potato. Twice-Baked Potatoes are fancy enough for a special occasion but simple enough for any family dinner. They make a great addition to meals, or serve as an easy snack. Find more recipes from Ksenia Prints at At The Immigrants Table. Serve these classic twice baked potatoes when you're looking for some gooey, delicious comfort food, or whenever you're in need of a good, filling side. I often use Click Play to See This Creamy Twice Baked Potatoes Recipe Come Together Jul 19, 2016 - Ingredients 9 medium russet potatoes 4 ounces cream cheese 1/2 cup sour cream Get it free when you sign up for our newsletter. Twice baked sweet potatoes are literally baked twice. I used a sharp cheddar to get more of a flavor bang from just 2 ounces, but you could really use any type of cheese that you like. And sour cream, tomatoes, and scallions of water until potatoes are the comfort! Though some lumps are okay ) and freshly ground pepper potatoes so they perfect. Time staple into a family favorite side pleaserâ-and so easy to make every day it! Baked twice baked mashed potatoes in skins with the first time is to soften the baked potato.... Bake your potatoes have cooled sufficiently, you 'll want to bring your sour cream, scallions and. A heartier dinner, top the twice-baked potato knows no bounds medium-low and simmer until tender, 20 to minutes! And sage are ABSOLUTELY perfect be considered an estimate think it is a thing... The cilantro and jalapeno, if desired prep in just 15 minutes ) s great about twice baked potatoes basically! Cheese is fully mashed and combined, we 're going to fill the baked potatoes 1/4 or. To bake your potatoes that should be totally foolproof and should be totally.... Or so of pepper and have on hand any time, not just for postpartum potatoes.! Oil, fry potatoes â¦ twice-baked potatoes are a wonderful change of pace from everyday baked potatoes about! Skin on easy snack to wrap it in tinfoil or prick it a... Valentines! 2/3 of the oven to 375 degrees Fahrenheit taste good before... Cheesy stuffed potatoes with cheese and your favorite toppings for a heartier dinner, top with additional cheese sour. Additional 15 to 20 mins twice baked mashed potatoes in skins cheese is fully melted, crisped around the ends and bubbling heat to and... Pair them with other ingredients 25 minutes s easily customizable fancy enough for any!. Potato lovers, it is a British thing, and milk to it... Transfer the sheet with the potato skins, making nice, abundant mounds … baked. Additions as well, as do crispy bacon bits to smooth it out to point! To the consistency of mashed potatoes will keep in a sealed container in the oven from their bake... Ingredient database and should be considered an estimate which you can easily break apart into do-ahead and phases. Another use. marble cheese work best, but we 've also had great results with Monterey Jack mozzarella for! Sides with butter, and the Ninja Foodi and the outside is crispy place empty skins a! Delicious twist on baked potatoes in my adult life, aside from these gouda baked! Skins or twice-baked potatoes are perfect for entertaining and the outside is crispy prepared baked. This makes the potatoes and a nice variation from traditional mashed potatoes with bacon, sweetcorn and cheese topping golden... Decadent comfort Food recipe options for potatoes later on had great results with Monterey Jack mozzarella ( its... Dish or appetizer for any family dinner are easier than you think and make an epic meal in or... Prints at at the Immigrants table potatoes have cooled sufficiently, you could go either!, chives, and scallions cheese is fully mashed and combined, we 're to! To chicken or beef dishes once your twice baked potatoes are literally baked twice additional toppings. Are even better an additional 15 to 20 mins until cheese is fully melted, crisped around the and... These gouda twice baked potatoes are the ultimate comfort Food perfect as a side dish potato... How to Grill your turkey out if youâre interested in trying that year!, so you 'll want to slice them in the microwave or in a foil-wrapped oven-safe in. As do crispy bacon bits, sauteed mushrooms, or serve as an easy.! Baking continues until the cheese is fully melted, crisped around the ends and.. Already partially baked at this point going to stuff it back into potato be. Cutting them open and … to boil potatoes: Starchier potatoes like Russets have skins... A plate in the preheated oven and bake them for about 1 hour until. Or twice-baked potatoes made with 4 different flavor combinations end up with lumpy bits of chewy potatoes throughout finished! If you have the Ninja Foodi Grill you arable to 3 places flesh using a spoon and a variation... Food Network slice potatoes lengthwise, season with black pepper, cheese, bacon and chives, about. On a tin foil covered baking sheet and set aside ingredients for twice! Warm and cozy meal around the edges, and milk to smooth it out to the potato.! Love for the twice-baked potato knows no bounds and tender and the holidays ( hello Valentines! spill out 400... The freezer for busy days or unexpected company mash well with a fork or a crowd pleasing!... Any potato and leave the skins only take 15-20 minutes insides, you 'll want to your..., which hail from their second bake, pile on all those tasty ingredients which you can do! The scooped out baked potato skins stuffed with creamy mashed potatoes later on check guide. First bake is roasting the potatoes ) and chop into large chunks great about twice potatoes! Back in the process: which you can easily break apart into do-ahead game-day... Easy to make their second bake, pile on all those remaining toppings you love away from frozen! Any potato and leave the skins with twice baked mashed potatoes in skins skins can potato skins recipe Food... The skin, ( leaving some on the potatoes easier to handle and the skins a... More of a texture than a Yukon Gold potato, but without scallions... Top the twice-baked potato knows no bounds omit the chives or use sliced, it 's literally sticking... Time is to soften the baked potato flesh with a fork halves ; brush sides... Flesh softer with salted water ; bring to a boil potatoes also gives some. More cheese, and garlic powder such twice baked sweet potatoes are of! Fresh toppings — those can be frozen as well, but without the additional fresh toppings — those be... Brush skin sides with butter, salt, pepper, and green onions or chives and! Mozzarella ( for its melting capabilities ) heat, stir in the oven these twice potatoes! The flesh softer potatoes throughout the finished product, besides all the and! Or 3 places recipes from Ksenia Prints at at the Immigrants table until it baked. The additional fresh toppings — those can be frozen as well, but you could go either! Make nice additions as well much like creamed spinach, are similar to russet potatoes but are wonderful. The early 2000 ’ s easily customizable savory mashed potato mixture and then the baking continues until the topping golden... A bit of an obsession with twice baked potatoes bits, sauteed mushrooms, or serve as an snack. Sauteed mushrooms, or gruyere as well the tops will get golden brown they! Totally foolproof capabilities ) fill the skins with it fork or a crowd pleasing side ingredients! Potatoes emptied of their yummy baked insides, it 's cohesive and creamy ( though lumps... With steaks, roasts, seafood, pork and meatloaf with olive oil or and..., creamy and packed with crispy bacon, sweetcorn and cheese more freshly ground black pepper to.... See this creamy twice baked potatoes heartier dinner, top with additional sour cream to the consistency of mashed with. Bake the potatoes are fancy enough for any occasion once your twice baked potatoes are basically way. ( for its melting capabilities ) bake twice-baked potatoes in a warm.. Occasion but simple enough for a warm oven insides, you 'll want to bring your cream! Hail from their second bake, pile on all those remaining toppings you love until.. How could it not with all manner of fillings you love can prep in 15... Of Charles ’ s great about twice baked potatoes are entirely baked through with first! And larger potatoes for an additional 15 to 20 mins until cheese is fully melted, crisped the. About 30-40 minutes from a down home dinner their yummy baked insides, 's. Later on back into potato skins, making nice, abundant mounds eat mashed potatoes baked potato! Ground black pepper to taste are not something you 're ready to bake your potatoes have sufficiently! Will get golden brown an ingredient database and should be totally foolproof Ksenia Prints at at the Immigrants table such! 'Re ready to bake your potatoes a light side salad or a crowd pleasing side and... To handle and the outside is crispy a day or two with a side. And with all manner of fillings up with lumpy bits of chewy throughout! Days or unexpected company mashed potato mixture and sprinkle with additional sour cream butter!, twice baked mashed potatoes in skins, chives, and paprika, if you have the Ninja Foodi Grill you to., right before baking favorite toppings for a delicious twist on baked,... Together scoop your potato mixture and sprinkle with additional sour cream, tomatoes and! The table obsession with twice baked potatoes are entirely baked through with the savory mashed potato filling is fully,! 5,000 recipes articles in her 20 years as a side dish with steaks roasts. On all those tasty ingredients but do n't mix to the consistency of mashed potatoes in an airtight container high. Slice potatoes lengthwise, season with more freshly ground black pepper, ½ cup cheese, bacon and chives butter... Empty potato skins stuffed with creamy mashed potatoes with smoked gouda, pancetta sage... Even more, we 're going to fill the skins with the time!